Which are Better: Oils or Lotions?

Oils vs. lotions

When standing at the skin care aisle of your local market, it’s no doubt that you’re probably vortexed by the plethora of moisturizing options. After browsing through pretty labels and maybe a little sampling, you either end up with an oil or lotion in your cart.

What’s the difference between the two? Aren’t they both going to offer the same moisturizing benefits?

This is yet another “skintroversial” topic.

Both options can be incorporated into a facial and body routine, and each contain their own unique benefits for maintaining beautiful skin.

So, what’s the most suitable moisturizer for your skin type, and which will help you “turn back the clock?”

Lotions

Who doesn’t love a silky body lotion? Luxurious, creamy, buttery and whipped. You name it, they’ve made it.

Lotions are created by blending oil and water together. However, since oil and water do not mix on their own, wax is needed to emulsify them. Depending on the ratio of these three ingredients, the end result ranges from a light textured lotion to a heavy cream.

The presence of wax in face and body lotion formulas creates an “occlusive” layer on the skin, which locks in moisture. While this sounds ideal for those with dry skin types, wax can potentially build up on the skin, leading to clogged pores and breakouts. Also, since oil is a more active ingredient, and wax is more or less a “filler” ingredient, this waxy build up may prevent the amazing nutrients from the oil from actually penetrating into the skin.

Another downfall of lotion is that the presence of water in a formula requires some type of preservative to keep mold and bacteria from growing inside the product. Unfortunately, most preservatives on the market today are toxic and not skin-friendly. Truly “natural” preservatives are rare, so checking labels is a must and we encourage you to find the cleanest options! We use Aspen Bark Extract to preserve the integrity of our natural formulas.

Benefits of Using Lotion on Your Skin

  • Replenishes moisture in the skin
  • Leaves skin feeling soft, supple and hydrated
  • Soothes dry, chapped and rough skin texture
  • Additional ingredients in lotion formulas include aloe, vitamin E, shea butter, sunflower oil, and extracts, which all have their own beneficial properties
  • Lotions help those with sensitive skin

Lotions definitely bring something to the table. But as you go through all of that trouble of lathering on your daily moisturizer of choice, you might want to consider if your skin is would receive more benefits from an oil-based formula?

Oils

If you’re familiar with Annmarie Skin Care, you know we’re a huge fan of oils. They are the primary base for the majority of our products (with a lot of love and herbs infused into them!).

I like to refer to oils as the ‘crème de la crème,' because they are an essential component of your typical lotion or cream, and can also be used alone for superior moisturization. In fact, pure oils have been used for thousands of years in ancient beauty rituals from around the world.

Oils have extremely high nutrient and antioxidant levels. They are 100% active and are easily absorbed into the skin since they don’t contain any fillers. As we age, the oil (sebum) that our skin produces starts to deplete, so it only makes sense to replenish the lipid barrier by applying oils that our skin will lovingly soak right up! See, if we don’t lubricate the skin effectively, then fine lines and wrinkles start to show up.

A common skin care myth is that oils will clog pores and make you break out, especially for acne-prone skin types. This is wildly untrue! Oils have the amazing ability to balance the skin. Let’s ditch the oil-free hype because all skin types can benefit tremendously from these gifts of nature. Try our Herbal Facial Oil for Normal and Combination Skin which is in a base of grapeseed oil, a very light-textured oil suitable for even the most sensitive of skin types.

Benefits of Using Oil on Your Skin

  • Oils hold in moisture
  • Since oils deliver antioxidants, vitamins and essential fatty acids to the skin effectively, they are the optimal choice for an anti-aging moisturizer
  • A little oil goes a long way, making them the more cost effective choice (applying to wet skin will increase absorption, providing complete coverage in as little as a few drops)
  • No preservative is needed to store an oil (miron glass is recommended for extended shelf life)
  • Oils are easily welcomed by the skin and will not clog pores

Do keep in mind that the quality of an oil also reflects its performance on the skin. Look for oils that say “cold-pressed” or “CO2-extracted.” Always choose organic when possible and avoid chemical additives such as fragrances (parfum). Oils are often infused with herbs, so if the ingredient on the label are names of flowers and plants, you’ve likely found a good quality oil. Your skin is just waiting to take in all the juicy benefits!

Next time you need to re-stock your moisturizer, experiment with what responds and works best for your skin type. We recommend oils because of the amazing benefits, but some people also love using lotion like Radiant Skin Silk on their faces and have great results.

What moisturizer do you prefer? What noticeable benefits have you received from oils? Share with us!

by Abby Stoecker
Licensed Esthetician

Sources:

http://www.organicgardening.com/living/lotion-or-oil

How to Make an Herbal Body Cream


Winter, Ruth. ‘A Consumer's Dictionary of Cosmetic Ingredients: Complete Information About the Harmful and Desirable Ingredients in Cosmetics and Cosmeceutical’. Harmony; February 10, 2010.
Aguino, Kathy. ‘Skin Care Oils: Natural Plant Oils For Your Face, Body, And Hair’. Amazon Digital Services. November 29, 2014.

Posted in:

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Same! I’ve been using oils for most my life, & thoroughly enjoy the benefits. A lot of people ask me what I do & I tell them OIL !! There’s an oil appropriate for every skin type & I switch them up seasonally too. (Something a little richer for the winter / lighter for the summertime – I’m a greasy gal in the summer!) so if you’re on the fence, don’t be afraid! Take a chance & watch the magic happen. You will fall in love with your skin! If you’re looking for a product to take the leap with Annmarie Gianni’s is a safe bet. Peace Love & Oil

  2. I’m 85, always looking for the best skin care. I’ve found it in Annmarie.I use the ant-aging products as well as coconut Honey Mask, the exfoliating masks, hand cream and coconut oil. I like the look of moisture rather than cosmetics. When I announce my age, which I’m proud to do, most people say “No way, maybe 70”. So grateful to you and your ethics. Joy

  3. I’ve tried a multitude of oils and oil blends on my skin as my moisturizer (incl. your herbal facial oil and anti-aging oil), and they just do NOT work for me despite how MUCH I wanted them to. No matter how little I use, they all just SIT on my skin (even after rubbing in, obviously) making it look downright greasy. Even rosehip oil, which is said to be one of the more drying oils, doesn’t work for me. As a result, I’ve defaulted to using serums (which I quite like) and facial creams/moisturizers. I don’t understand why the oils behave that way on my (facial) skin, though. Has anyone ever encountered that or had a similar experience? Admin, any insights?

    • Hi Liz,

      That’s great that the serum is working so well for you! Aloe absorbs really easily into the skin, and both of our serums do include a bit of oil, so are you are getting the moisturizing benefits as well. My advice for you, if you’d like to use a facial oil, would be to exfoliate first with something like our Dead Sea Scrub. http://shop.annmariegianni.com/Dead-Sea-Scrub-50ml_p_33.html This will help you absorb the oil better.

  4. My recommendation for optimizing the oil absorption is to simply spray a toning most of your choice after you apply the oil. Water increases skin permeability, therefore the oil drives into the skin deeper 🙂 this will also dilute the oil a bit, for those who get that “greasy” complexion after applying an oil. Don’t forget to gently massage it into the skin !

  5. Thank you for sharing all of your wisdom and creating such a beautiful product line, Annmarie. I absolutely LOVE using oils on my skin, and have only recently, within the last year, discovered their amazing benefits. The only concern is making sure that I’m also protecting my skin from harmful rays, so I use an organic moisturizer with an SPF, during the day and on top of my oils, for protection. How do you feel about that? Do you have a better recommendation for me? I appreciate your advice, and I’m eager to hear from you.

  6. Wonderful, beautiful article! Aestheticians need to know this information and so do our clients! Most people can’t get that “oil clogs and makes me break out” myth out of their heads.

  7. Great post! Oils have made a huge difference in my skin. I love that they are so concentrated. My own oil production has normalized since using oils on my skin. I used your anti aging oil in the winter and just ordered a sample of the herbal oil, which I also love. Coconut oil is wonderful on my body. I’ve posted reviews of many of your products on my blog. Annmarie Gianni is the first company I have found that makes truly natural products that are also highly effective. Love them!

  8. Happy to have discovered your website! Just FYI though, I tried to take the quiz to find my “Skin Score,” but the link took me to a blank white page ???? Please let me know if the quiz returns.

    Thank you so much!

    S.P. Wilds

    • Hi there!

      I’m sorry you weren’t able to take the skin quiz, we’ve been periodically updating it so you might have an older version. Try to delete your browsing history and click the skin quiz again on any of the blog posts 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comments (27 and counting)